Supporting Assessment Design at Key Stage 3

Supporting Assessment Design at Key Stage 3

Writing fair assessments

Before you write an assessment, make sure that you know what its purpose is. Creating a mark scheme or success criteria at the time of designing an assessment helps ensure that the content and question types in the assessment are appropriate. Teachers should also be able to understand and apply the mark scheme or success criteria accurately, fairly and consistently.

Content in assessments

Content should:

  • be appropriate for the method of assessment;
  • be consistent with and reflect the breadth of the scheme of work;
  • reflect age-appropriate versions of expectations of Key Stage 4 assessments;
  • be fit for purpose;
  • permit reasonable adjustments; and
  • avoid bias.

The level of demand should:

  • be consistent:
    • across all options for tasks;
    • with other assessments (departmental and across the curriculum);
    • with previous assessments; and
    • with class work and homework learning opportunities; and
  • facilitate:
    • differentiation; and
    • allocation of a range of marks to reflect knowledge and skills.

Communication in assessments

The language in assessments must:

  • communicate requirements:
    • clearly;
    • concisely; and
    • using correct spelling, grammar and punctuation; and
  • reflect rubrics in the scheme of work or specification.

Stimulus materials, images, diagrams and charts should:

  • be clear;
  • avoid ambiguity; and
  • avoid bias.

Assessment presentation should take into account:

  • amount of time allocated;
  • number of questions;
  • total marks;
  • marks per question;
  • clear layout;
  • question numbers;
  • page numbers; and
  • sufficient space to record answers.

Consistency in marking

An effective mark scheme enables teachers to:

  • be accurate, fair and consistent in their marking; and
  • differentiate accurately and consistently between a range of attainments by pupils.

Effective mark schemes:

  • ensure assessments are marked consistently and fairly;
  • provide the marker with a range of possible credit-worthy responses a pupil can make appropriate to the subject; and
  • set out the criteria against which marks are allocated to pupils’ responses.

Appropriate use of language and stimulus materials

When choosing language and stimulus materials, ensure that they:

  • are appropriate for the age of the pupils who may sit the assessment;
  • enable pupils to demonstrate their level of attainment;
  • require relevant knowledge, skills and understanding;
  • reflect the level and objective of the assessment;
  • are clear and unambiguous (unless ambiguity forms part of the assessment); and
  • are not likely to cause unnecessary offence to pupils.

Reflection

The presentation/slideshow below shows four assessment questions that are used as examples in Fair Access by Design: Guidance for awarding organisations on designing high-quality and inclusive qualifications (Qualifications Wales and CCEA Regulation, 2019).

Reflecting on fairness in assessment, consider the following for each question:

  • Decide what, if anything, you would change about the question. (Click within the presentation for a hint.)
  • Write a fairer version of the question. (Click for a suggestion.)